Sz

The dorm living room was a chaotic nest of discarded snack bags, tangled charging cables, and sprawling limbs. It was one of those rare nights where the schedule had cleared early, leaving the eight members of Ateez with nothing but time and a dangerous amount of nostalgia.

"I found it," Wooyoung announced, his voice reaching a pitch that usually signaled trouble. He was hunched over his laptop, the blue light reflecting in his mischievous eyes. "The external hard drive from the old practice room. I think this has the raw footage from the Treasure era."

Hongjoong, who had been trying to doze off against the arm of the sofa, sat up instantly. "The stuff the company didn't want the fans to see? Or the stuff we didn't want the fans to see?"

"Both," Wooyoung grinned, clicking a file. "Come on, everyone. Come look at how tiny we were."

One by one, they gathered. Jongho abandoned his fruit plate; Yunho draped himself over the back of the couch like a giant golden retriever; San and Mingi squeezed into the space on the floor. Seonghwa, ever the mother hen, hovered at the edge, already bracing himself for the cringe that was surely coming.

The first video flickered to life. It was a grainy, handheld recording from a basement studio, dated just weeks after their debut.

"Oh my god," San gasped, hiding his face in his hands. "Is that... is that me?"

On screen, a nineteen-year-old Choi San was staring intensely into the lens. He was startlingly thin, his jawline sharp enough to cut paper, and his hair was styled in a choppy, jet-black fringe that nearly covered his eyes. He was wearing an oversized hoodie with safety pins attached to the sleeves, looking every bit the brooding, emo teenager.

"You look like you're about to write a very dark poem about the rain," Yeosang remarked, his voice deadpan but his eyes sparkling with amusement.

"I thought I was being cool!" San wailed, peeking through his fingers. "I thought the 'dark and mysterious' vibe was what the fans wanted."

"You looked like you hadn't slept since 2017," Mingi laughed, his deep voice rumbling through the room.

"Look who's talking!" San pointed at the screen as the video transitioned to a clip of a dance rehearsal.

The camera zoomed in on Mingi, who was trying to master a complex footwork sequence. Back then, his skin hadn't yet been perfected by high-end dermatologists and expensive foundations. A cluster of stubborn breakouts lined his jaw and forehead, the mark of a teenager working through stress and hormones.

Mingi let out a strangled noise. "Turn it off. Delete it. Burn the hard drive."

"No way," Yunho said, pulling Mingi back down. "You were cute, Mingi-ya. Look at those cheeks. You were just a baby giant."

"I look like a strawberry with all those spots," Mingi grumbled, though a small, fond smile tugged at his lips.

The video cut again, this time to a behind-the-scenes moment from a photoshoot. The room went quiet for a second as a very different Park Seonghwa appeared on screen.

Current Seonghwa was known for his elegance, his kindness, and his habit of cleaning the dorm at three in the morning. But the Seonghwa on the screen was a different beast entirely. He was wearing a leather harness over a black shirt, his hair slicked back with an aggressive amount of gel. He wasn't smiling. He was giving the camera a look of pure, unadulterated coldness.

"The legend," Hongjoong whispered, shaking his head.

"I forgot how much you scared me back then," Jongho admitted, looking at the screen with newfound respect. "You didn't say a word for like, three months. You just walked around looking like you owned the building."

"The CEO was actually intimidated by him," Wooyoung cackled, slapping his knee. "Remember? He told the managers he didn't want to give Seonghwa-hyung notes on his performance because he was afraid Seonghwa would just stare him into silence."

Seonghwa sighed, rubbing his temples. "I was just so nervous. I thought if I acted tough, no one would see how much I was shaking inside. I wasn't a 'hard boy,' I was a terrified boy."

"Well, it worked," Hongjoong said. "You looked like the leader of a biker gang. I used to check with you before I made any big decisions because I thought you might hit me."

"I have never hit anyone in my life!" Seonghwa protested, his voice returning to its usual gentle, high-pitched tone.

They continued to scroll through the files, the laughter growing louder with every "fashion choice" and awkward interview answer. They saw Hongjoong buried under a mountain of discarded lyric sheets, his eyes bloodshot from staying up all night in a studio that was little more than a closet. They saw Yunho and Wooyoung attempting to do a comedy skit that ended in them falling over a pile of equipment. They saw Yeosang sitting quietly in the corner of every shot, looking like a porcelain doll that had been forced to join a pirate crew.

"We were so small," San said softly, the humor fading into a comfortable warmth. "The practice room felt so big back then. Everything felt so big."

"We were desperate," Hongjoong added, leaning back. "Everything was a life-or-death situation. If we missed a step, we thought the world would end. If we didn't look 'cool' enough, we thought we'd fail."

The video on the screen changed to a candid moment. It wasn't a rehearsal or a professional shoot. It was just the eight of them sitting on the floor of their old, cramped dorm, sharing a single large bowl of ramyeon. They were sweaty, their hair was a mess, and they were all talking over each other.

"Look at us," Yunho pointed out. "Even back then, we couldn't just eat in peace."

"I remember that night," Yeosang said suddenly. "That was the night we found out we were going to film the music video in Morocco. We were so scared about the budget."

On the screen, a younger Jongho was holding a chopstick like a microphone. "When we get famous," the boy in the video said, his voice cracking slightly, "I'm going to buy my mom a house. And I’m going to buy us a dorm where we don't have to sleep in bunk beds three-high."

The modern-day Jongho looked down at his lap, a small, proud smile on his face. He hadn't just bought his mom a house; he had become one of the most respected vocalists of his generation.

"We did it, didn't we?" Mingi asked, his voice unusually quiet.

"We're still doing it," Hongjoong corrected him. "But yeah. We did the hard part. We survived being those kids."

Wooyoung clicked on the final video in the folder. It was a short clip, only thirty seconds long. It showed the eight of them standing in a circle, hands piled in the center, just moments before they stepped onto their first-ever debut stage.

The camera was shaky, held by a nervous staff member. You could hear the muffled roar of the crowd in the distance—a crowd that was so much smaller than the ones they played for now, but a crowd that felt like the entire world to them at the time.

"Eight makes one team," the young, high-strung voices shouted in unison on the recording.

The video cut to black, leaving the eight men in the dim light of their current, luxurious living room. For a moment, no one spoke. The contrast between the thin, acne-scarred, "hard-acting" boys on the screen and the polished, confident men in the room was staggering.

"San-ah," Seonghwa said, breaking the silence. "You don't need the emo fringe anymore. You're plenty cool without it."

San laughed, wiping a stray tear from his eye. "And you don't need to scare the CEO anymore, Hyung. You’re much better as the guy who cries during movies and tucks us in."

"Hey!" Seonghwa protested, though he didn't look truly offended.

"I miss the energy of those days sometimes," Yunho mused, stretching his long legs out. "That feeling of having absolutely nothing to lose because we had nothing to begin with."

"I don't miss the bunk beds," Yeosang said firmly. "Or the ramyeon for every meal."

"True," Hongjoong agreed. He stood up, stretching his back until it popped. "But I'm glad we have the videos. It's good to remember the ghosts."

"Ghosts?" Mingi tilted his head.

"The ghosts of who we used to be," Hongjoong explained. "They’re still here. They’re the ones who did all the work so we could be here tonight."

Wooyoung shut the laptop with a soft click. "Well, those ghosts were very cringey, and I’m glad I have the only copy of this drive. If any of this leaks, I’m blaming Mingi’s safety-pin phase."

"That was San's phase!" Mingi shouted, lunging for a pillow to throw at Wooyoung.

"Whatever! You both looked like you were auditioning for a rock band in a garage!"

Within seconds, the sentimental atmosphere vanished, replaced by the familiar chaos of Ateez. Pillows flew, laughter echoed off the high ceilings, and someone—likely Wooyoung—ended up in a headlock.

As Seonghwa watched his members bicker and play, he thought back to the boy in the leather harness on the screen. That boy had been so afraid of being seen as weak that he had built a wall of ice. But looking around at the warmth of the room, Seonghwa realized that the ice hadn't melted because he'd gotten older or more famous. It had melted because he’d found seven people who didn't care if he was "hard" or "cool."

They had seen the acne, the emo hair, the thin frames, and the fear, and they had stayed anyway.

"Alright, alright!" Seonghwa called out, though he was smiling. "Pick up the snack bags. If we're going to be world-class artists, we can at least have a clean floor."

"Yes, Captain!" they shouted back in a messy, uncoordinated chorus.

They weren't the same boys from the basement anymore. They were stronger, wiser, and much better dressed. But as they worked together to tidy the room, the echoes of that old debut-day chant seemed to linger in the air—a reminder that while their faces might change and their shadows might grow, the heart of the team remained exactly where it had always been.